Curly's Corner Shop, the blog!

South Shields premier political blog

Why I will be voting against AV

with 6 comments

Referendum choice on May 5th could mean a second choice government.

The trouble with any voting system in use in any liberal western democracy is that it doesn’t suit everybody, it never will, and some compromise has to be made, minority views accepted and respected, and the majority view must never be used like a sledgehammer.

I will nail my colours to the mast here, I’m quite happy with our first past the post system, it is easy to understand and comprehend, it retains a vital link between a single member and a single constituency, and it represents one person one vote. Sure it has its problems, in some places you may feel that your vote doesn’t carry a lot of weight, especially if you are a supporter of a minority party in a constituency which heavily favours one of the major parties, but in our democracy it is the role of the candidates to enthuse people with a positive manifesto to attract votes, not a negative message to to encourage you NOT to vote for other candidates.

It has lost favour principally because of the large amount of votes stacked up in favour of the Liberal Democrats thinly spread across the country which has not translated into seats in the same proportion as Labour or Conservatives, and in the resulting horse trading following our last general election David Cameron and the Conservatives had to concede this referendum in order to keep Nick Clegg’s party in the deal.

My greatest fears about AV (alternative vote) is that we may end up with many MPs who were not the most favoured in their constituencies, but the least unpopular instead, this is not a very inspiring situation. Indeed the recent election of Labour leader Ed Miliband was the result of second and third choice votes being redistributed to him as the least unpopular candidate, his brother David, the South Shields MP was by far the most popular candidate in the early rounds of the contest but was pipped at the post as the minor candidates fell out and their votes were counted a second and third time. I find this inherently unfair, especially as I put so much faith in “one person, one vote”, at a general election we often see fringe candidates in South Shields exercising their right to seek election, under the AV system where we are encouraged to rank the candidates in order of preference, supporters of minor parties may have more weight to their vote and they may even see their vote counted twice or three times depending upon how long it takes one candidate to acquire the necessary 50% criteria that the AV supporters are looking for.

If on the other hand, someone like David Miliband (purely for example) were to receive 52% of the total ballot on the first count, then all of those second, third, and more choices will have been completely wasted. Until the next Boundary Commission comes up with constituencies with roughly even numbers of electors, we will still have many seats where this will happen, solid Labour seats and solid Conservative seats, along with a few solid Lib-Dem seats too, however in many constituencies where the current sitting MP does not enjoy that majority support the votes cast for minority parties become very important indeed. We ought to remember that some of them have very extreme policies too, but their supporters will get a second bite of the cherry and perhaps even a third, and we could see a number of MPs elected because of redistributed votes who would normally end up in second or third place in the ballot. As a result, the middle or third party could acquire sufficient seats to form a government, or at least hold the upper hand in a coalition, based purely on being the least unpopular amongst voters, rather than the party with the most favoured pre election manifesto. In effect our government may be one of second choice rather than first choice.

The most likely reality is that most Labour or Conservative supporters would choose a Liberal Democrat as their second choice, and in some seats this could easily condemn their first choice to a defeat. I do not like this idea of some votes counting more than others! Think of it this way, in a tight fight the victor could well have had two or three votes cast his way by thousands of people, whilst those in second or third place only received one vote per elector – fair and balanced?

I don’t want my MP sent to the House of Commons to represent the people of South Shields with their passive acceptance, I don’t want a government to be formed by passive acceptance, I want my representative or my government to have approval, and therefore I am happy to vote for the retention of our current system and allow the majority of MPs in the House to form a representative government – I just wish they didn’t have a fixed five year term (but that’s another argument).

Finally it alarms and frightens me that our centuries old system of forming a government could be voted out by less than a third of the population – just consider how many people will take part in the referendum on May 5th!

add to :: Add to Blinkslist :: add to furl :: Digg it :: add to ma.gnolia :: Stumble It! :: add to simpy :: seed the vine :: :: :: TailRank :: post to facebook

Written by curly

April 4, 2011 at 2:56 pm

6 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. You’ve got my vote on that one Curly. I wonder why there are safe Labour and safe Conservative seats?


    April 4, 2011 at 3:51 pm

    • At its most simplistic you could call it tribalism, with many like minded people all living together in the same area, and a large amount of “vote the way I’ve always voted son”. The more interesting constituencies are the ones where general elections are fought and won, the marginals, their demographics are genuinely mixed and far more representative of the larger population, in essence the more marginals we have the better! These are the seats where swing matters most.


      April 4, 2011 at 4:22 pm

      • First past the post with me too. Yet another expensive pointless exercise, not least because the turn out for the referendum could be low, difficult enough to get people out to vote in local elections, yet alone what is perceived to be a time wasting referendum. I am sick to death of hearing the phrase “wasted votes” from politicians elected by the current system, they are probably contributing to the culture of “not bothering to cast a vote”; ironic when people are fighting and dying to try and secure “Western style democracy” in their countries.


        April 4, 2011 at 7:11 pm

  2. LLB have we (the west) took the time to think and ask if our western democracy was wanted, needed and in the best interests of these countries? Feudalism has served Japan well enough as well as tribalism in other countries.

    Or do you subcribe to comic book foreign policy of the US.

    Are you also pompus in real life too?


    April 9, 2011 at 9:02 pm

    • The AV campaign is turning out to be the politicaly damaging irrelevant sideshow which I “pompously” predicted. The situation is laughable given the serious domestic and foreign policy issues which our first past the post “coalition” are having to try and deal with whilst hurling insults and accusations at each other re the conduct of their AV campaigns. Other countries may have allegedly “comic book policies” but we are becoming a laughing stock, as would any organisation large or small be, where senior and significant individuals are sniping at, and making serious derogatory accusations about each other on an almost hourly basis.


      April 24, 2011 at 10:11 am

  3. Personalised comments and incorrect assumptions about people add 0 to debate or discussion of serious issues.


    April 10, 2011 at 8:08 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: